Electoral System and Level of Party Fragmentation in Republic of Bulgaria (1991 – 2001)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.37075/RP.2004.1.05Abstract
Electoral system has a direct effect over the intensity of the competitive and cooperative relations between the political parties on an electoral and parliamentary level, which determines in a great extent the form of the party system and the parties fragmentation. The present study is dedicated to the analysis of the active electoral system in the Republic of Bulgaria during the period 1991-2001, as well as to its influence over the parties fragmentation within the country.In the First Part of the study it is given a short description of the proportional system in the multimandate electoral regions (MERs), as well as its effects. There are formed the main thesis of the Study hypotheses.In the Second Part are reviewed the main approaches of research of the degree of the influence of the electoral systems over the parliamentary systems and the degree of parties fragmentation. In the Third Part, the Bulgarian electoral system is characterized and some assumptions are formed in regard to its effects.In the Forth Part, it is presented a detailed analysis of the Bulgarian case and are formed the results of the Study, which support the thesis that the proportional electoral system in the MERs, due to the methods for distribution of the mandates and the V. P. Ondt’s method (rule) in particular, as well as the high 4 % electoral barrier, provides different bales of disproportional effect on the parliamentary elections in Bulgaria within the period 1991-2001. This effect has its highest value in 1991 and the lowest one in 1997. This objectively determines the limited (low) fragmentation of the parliamentary party system as the number of the relevant and/or effective parties from one election to another is limited – from 3 to 5 parties or coalitions under the „numeral criterion“. There is a concentration effect of the electoral system over the party system.The effectiveness of the proportional system in the MERs in Bulgaria within the period 1991 – 2001 depends not so much on the concentration of the party system, but on the political behavior of the parliamentary majorities and the opposition. And this is the major reason for the political government and even institutional instability in 1991-1997. The financial and internal political stability which occurred in Bulgaria in 1997-2001, as well as the opening of Bulgaria towards the European structures, happened in return to the negative consequences of the concentration of power resources and partocracy, instead of the control and balance of the three powers, corruption and clientelism of the different political structures, the party conflicts and partisanship and the decrease in the interaction of the parliamentary parties with other party formations and most over with structures of the Civil Society.Two trends occurred – of marginalization of the small parties and of some relevant party formations such as BBB and the Eurolefts, and of a deepening electoral absentism (unwillingness to vote), which highest point was recorded in 1997.References
Law on the Election of National Representatives, Municipal Councilors, and Mayors (LENMCM), State Gazette no. 69 from 1991.
Law on the Election of National Representatives (LENR), State Gazette no. 37 from 2001.
Law on Political Parties, State Gazette no. 69 from 1999.
Law on Political Parties, State Gazette no. 30 from 2001.
Instructions for Calculating the Results of Elections for National Representatives and Municipal Councilors. (1991). Central Election Commission.
Instructions for Calculating the Results of the Elections for People's Representatives. (1997). Central Election Commission.
Methodology for Determining the Number of Seats in Electoral Districts and the Results of Voting. (2001). Central Election Commission.
Bulletin of the elections for people's representatives held on 13 October 1991. (1991). CEC.
Bulletin of the Results of the Elections Held on December 18, 1994. (1994). CEC for the Election of National Representatives.
Bulletin of the Results of the Elections Held on April 19, 1997. (1997). CEC for the Election of National Representatives.
Bulletin of the Results of the Elections Held on 17 June 2001. (2001). CEC for the Election of National Representatives.
Фондация "Демократични традиции – Деметра" (1997). Bulgarian Elections (1990-1996). Results. Analyses. Trends. Foundation "Democratic Traditions - Demetra".
Golosov, G. V. (1998). Party System Formats in New Democracies: Institutional Factors of Instability and Fragmentation. Polis. Politicheskie Issledovaniya, 106-129. URL: https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=5078149 (accessed 2005-03-02)
Dal, Robert Alan (1999). On Democracy. Obsidian. ISBN: 954-8240-72-6
Duverger, Maurice (1995). The Semi-Presidential Regime (Check to the King). Sofia: St. Kliment Ohridski University Press. ISBN: 954-07-0524-X
Ivanov, K. & Tsanov, V. (1993). Mathematical commentary on some electoral systems. Obuchenie po matematika i informatika.
Korkinov, V. (1994). Improving the Distribution of Seats According to the Proportional Component of the Mixed Electoral System. "Politicheski izsledvaniya".
Nohlen, Dieter & Kasapovich, Miryana (1996). Electoral Systems in Eastern Europe. Sofia: Fondatsiya "Fridrikh Ebert", Regionalno byuro "Balkani".
Newland, RA (1993). Electoral Systems: Comparative Analysis. St. Kliment Ohridski University Press.
Improvement of the Electoral Legislation with Full Transparency and Consideration of Public Attitudes. Report of the Bulgarian Institute for Analyses and Research under the Contract of the "Democratic Network" Program. (1998). Bulgarian Institute for Analyses and Research.
Barcinkowski, A. (1984). Partie politwczne i systemy partyjne. Nauka o polityce. Prodrecznik akademicki (Ed. Bodnara, A.).
Beyme, Klaus Von (1984). Partien in Weslichen Demokratien. Zurich: Piper. ISBN: 978-3-492-00545-6
Dowse, R. E. & Hughes, J. A. (1972). Political sosiology. London: "John Willy and sons". ISBN: 978-0-471-22145-6
Duverger, M. (1976). Les partis politiques. "Libraire Armand Colin".
Nohlen, D. (1978). Die Wahlen systeme in der Welt. Zurich-Munhen: Piper.
Reilly, B. (1997). The International IDEA Hondbook of Electoral Systems Design. Stocholm: International IDEA. ISBN: 978-91-85391-18-9
Sartori, G. (1976). Parties and Party Systems. Framework for analysis. New York: "Cambridge University Press".
Sartori, G. (1990). Tipology of Party Systems. The West European Party System (Ed. Mair, P.).
R Taagepera & MS Shugart (1989). Seats and votes: The effects and determinants of electoral systems. New Haven: Yale University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0261-3794(89)90021-8
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2004 Radka Tsenova (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright to their works.
All publications are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license.